Just such is the manner in which nine readers out of ten judge of a book.They are ashamed to dislike what men who speak as having authority declare to be good.At present, however contemptible a poem or a novel may be, there is not the least difficulty in procuring favourable notices of it from all sorts of publications, daily, weekly, and monthly.In the meantime, little or nothing is said on the other side.The author and the publisher are interested in crying up the book.Nobody has any very strong interest in crying it down.Those who are best fitted to guide the public opinion think it beneath them to expose mere nonsense, and comfort themselves by reflecting that such popularity cannot last.This contemptuous lenity has been carried too far.It is perfectly true that reputations which have been forced into an unnatural bloom fade almost as soon as they have expanded; nor have we any apprehensions that puffing will ever raise any scribbler to the rank of a classic.It is indeed amusing to turn over some late volumes of periodical works, and to see how many immortal productions have, within a few months, been gathered to the poems of Blackmore and the novels of Mrs.
Behn; how many "profound views of human nature," and "exquisite delineations of fashionable manners," and "vernal, and sunny, and refreshing thoughts," and "high imaginings," and "young breathings," and "embodyings," and "pinings," and "minglings with the beauty of the universe," and "harmonies which dissolve the soul in a passionate sense of loveliness and divinity," the world has contrived to forget.The names of the books and of the writers are buried in as deep an oblivion as the name of the builder of Stonehenge.Some of the well-puffed fashionable novels of eighteen hundred and twenty-nine hold the pastry of eighteen hundred and thirty; and others, which are now extolled in language almost too high-flown for the merits of Don Quixote, will, we have no doubt, line the trunks of eighteen hundred and thirty-one.But, though we have no apprehensions that puffing will ever confer permanent reputation on the undeserving, we still think its influence most pernicious.Men of real merit will, if they persevere, at last reach the station to which they are entitled, and intruders will be ejected with contempt and derision.But it is no small evil that the avenues to fame should be blocked up by a swarm of noisy, pushing, elbowing pretenders, who, though they will not ultimately be able to make good their own entrance, hinder, in the mean time, those who have a right to enter.All who will not disgrace themselves by joining in the unseemly scuffle must expect to be at first hustled and shouldered back.Some men of talents, accordingly, turn away in dejection from pursuits in which success appears to bear no proportion to desert.Others employ in self-defence the means by which competitors, far inferior to themselves, appear for a time to obtain a decided advantage.There are few who have sufficient confidence in their own powers and sufficient elevation of mind, to wait with secure and contemptuous patience, while dunce after dunce presses before them.Those who will not stoop to the baseness of the modern fashion are too often discouraged.Those who do stoop to it are always degraded.
We have of late observed with great pleasure some symptoms which lead us to hope that respectable literary men of all parties are beginning to be impatient of this insufferable nuisance.And we purpose to do what in us lies for the abating of it.We do not think that we can more usefully assist in this good work than by showing our honest countrymen what that sort of poetry is which puffing can drive through eleven editions, and how easily any bellman might, if a bellman would stoop to the necessary degree of meanness, become a "master-spirit of the age." We have no enmity to Mr.Robert Montgomery.We know nothing whatever about him, except what we have learned from his books, and from the portrait prefixed to one of them, in which he appears to be doing his very best to look like a man of genius and sensibility, though with less success than his strenuous exertions deserve.We select him, because his works have received more enthusiastic praise, and have deserved more unmixed contempt, than any which, as far as our knowledge extends, have appeared within the last three or four years.His writing bears the same relation to poetry which a Turkey carpet bears to a picture.There are colours in the Turkey carpet out of which a picture might be made.There are words In Mr.Montgomery's writing which, when disposed in certain orders and combinations, have made, and will again make, good poetry.But, as they now stand, they seem to be put together on principle in such a manner as to give no image of anything "in the heavens above, or in the earth beneath, or in the waters under the earth."The poem on the Omnipresence of the Deity commences with a description of the creation, in which we can find only one thought which has the least pretension to ingenuity, and that one thought is stolen from Dryden, and marred in the stealing:
"Last, softly beautiful, as music's close, Angelic woman into being rose."The all-pervading influence of the Supreme Being is then described in a few tolerable lines borrowed from Pope, and a great many intolerable lines of Mr.Robert Montgomery's own.The following may stand as a specimen:
"But who could trace Thine unrestricted course, Though Fancy followed with immortal force?
There's not a blossom fondled by the breeze, There's not a fruit that beautifies the trees, There's not a particle in sea or air, But nature owns thy plastic influence there!